• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
the frugal farm girl logo transparent background

The Frugal Farm Girl

Living Simply, Growing Abundantly: Homesteading, Gardening, and Recipes on a Budget!

  • Live Debt Free
    • Frugal Living
    • Get out of Debt
    • Meal Planning
    • Couponing
  • Raise Your Own
    • Chickens
    • Ducks
    • Goats
    • Mini Pigs
    • Rabbits
  • Grow Your Own
    • Canning
    • Gardening
    • Homesteading
    • Recipes
  • Shop
  • Essays
  • About
a bunny laying on the grass nextr to an easter basket

Non-Candy Easter Basket Toy Filler Ideas for Toddlers and Kindergarteners

Home » Non-Candy Easter Basket Toy Filler Ideas for Toddlers and Kindergarteners

January 30, 2025

You know what’s worse than finding Easter grass all over your house for months after the holiday? Watching your kids stockpile a mountain of candy from egg hunts and Easter baskets! (Like, how much sugar can one body handle?)

Take advantage while your kids are little to fill their baskets with non-toy items and sprinkle in just a few sweet treats.

All of these are available on Amazon for easy-peasy shopping.

Here are some of my favorite ideas to make this Easter fun and candy-free!

easter basket non toy fillers

1. Hide ‘N’ Hatch Dino Eggs

Hide ‘N’ Hatch Dino Eggs on Amazon
Imagine cracking open an egg and finding a tiny dino that “grows” when soaked in water. I mean, how cute is that? Perfect for little explorers who love a mix of magic and science. Bonus? They’re reusable for bath-time fun afterward.

2. Mini Wooden Puzzle Eggs

Mini Wooden Puzzle Eggs on Amazon
These adorable puzzles are just the right size to fit into an Easter egg, and they challenge little hands and minds. Preschoolers and kindergartners will have a blast solving them. Plus, they’re sturdy enough to survive some enthusiastic tossing around.

3. Easter-Themed Pop-It Keychains

Easter Pop-It Keychains on Amazon
If your house has a Pop-It obsession like mine does, these mini Easter-themed ones are the perfect addition! Think bunny and chick shapes but small enough to pop into an egg. Great for fidgety fingers during car rides or quiet time.

4. Mini Stamps with Easter Patterns

Mini Easter Stamp Set on Amazon
Stamping is one of those classics that never gets old. This pack of mini stamps features bunny, egg, and flower designs. They’re perfect for decorating cards or adding flair to coloring pages—and best of all, they keep their hands busy for a while.

5. Wind-Up Bunny Toys

Wind-Up Easter Bunnies on Amazon
These wind-up toys are laugh-out-loud funny. Kids love racing them across the floor or pitting them against each other to see which one hops the fastest. Who knew a little winding gear could deliver so much joy?

6. Magic Grow Capsules – Easter Edition

Magic Grow Capsules on Amazon
These capsules magically transform into foam shapes when placed in water. Look for packs with the theme your child will love the best. There are lots of options. Watching them “grow” is like a mini science lesson—but way cooler.

7. Colorful Dino Erasers

Multi-Pack Dino Erasers on Amazon
These cute erasers aren’t just functional—they’re collectibles for budding dino enthusiasts. I love that they’re helpful for school but also double as tiny toys.

8. Pull-Back Cars (Mini Style)

Mini Pull-Back Cars on Amazon
These tiny cars are absolute winners for toddlers and kindergartners. Pull them back, and watch them zoom across the floor or table. Egg hunts turn into car races real quick!

9. Easter-Themed Finger Puppets

Easter Finger Puppets on Amazon
These stretchy, colorful puppets are cute as can be. Eggs filled with bunny and chick puppets can turn into more imaginative playtime—or, knowing my kids, hilarious finger battles.

10. Mini Building Brick Kits

Mini Easter Building Kits on Amazon
Lego-style sets with tiny bricks that build bunnies, chicks, or Easter eggs are perfect for older toddlers or kindergartners. Bonus points if your family already loves Lego since these mix right in.

11. Scratch Art Cards

Mini Scratch Art Easter Set on Amazon
These little treasures are especially fun for creative kids. Use a wooden stylus to reveal bright colors beneath. They make for mess-free art projects—and who doesn’t love that?

12. Glow-in-the-Dark Mini Bouncy Balls

Glow Bouncy Balls on Amazon
For egg hunts that go into the evening or just a fun novelty, glow-in-the-dark bouncy balls are a hit. Imagine the surprise when kids open an egg and find a glowing toy inside!

13. Mini Play-Doh Eggs

Play-Doh Easter Eggs on Amazon
You already know the magic of Play-Doh, right? These mini versions come packaged in Easter eggs. They’re great for squishy, creative play on Easter morning—or anytime, really.

14. Mini Musical Instruments

Mini Maracas and Instraments on Amazon
Introduce a little rhythm to your Easter celebration. Mini instruments like egg maracas or harmonicas make music fun and accessible—even if it means your house will be a little noisier than usual.

With options like puzzles, bouncy balls, and creative toys that keep playtime going, it’s easier to ditch the candy without losing the holiday magic.

Now, all that’s left is to grab a basket, fill it with these fun finds, and watch your little ones light up with excitement. Have fun, and remember—you deserve at least one chocolate bunny. 😉

a bunny laying on the grass nextr to an easter basket
Category: DIY, Frugal Living, holidays
Previous Post:A rustic metal bucket hangs on a wooden wall, filled with green leaves and speckled eggs in pastel shades, conveying a fresh, springtime feel.10 Farmhouse Easter Basket Ideas for Your Front Door or Wall
Next Post:Non-Candy Easter Basket Filler Ideas for Teensa teen holding up easter eggs with bunny ears on her head.

About Tasia

Welcome! I have desired my own backyard farm since I was a girl. I started a frugal crazy couponing lifestyle that allowed us to pay off our debt, create an online business and purchase our farmhouse and land. Join me as I share everything we are learning with you to encourage and inspire your dreams.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Pinterest

About Us |  Copyright Inquiry | Privacy Policy | Contact Us

The Best Chicken Planner

Stay organized and learn how to give your flock the best care

Download Now
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Pinterest

Copyright © 2025 · The Frugal Farm Girl · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Policy